Glenn Beck starts his Friday October 1, 2010 show writing on two blackboards.
- WHO ARE WE
- ARE WE DONE
He wants to know who are we as a country, and are we done yet as a country. Have we finished our job, have we freed all we needed to free, have we invented what we are supposed to invent?
Beck goes on to say “…they left bread crumbs all over the place. They knew we would fail,” speaking of Thomas Jefferson. He goes on to say in writings between Adams and Jefferson …”it’s going to fail. Jefferson said, yes, but the people will figure it out and they’ll remember what we were trying to do, and they will do it right this time.” Unfortunately Beck does not list any citing where he got this information.
He then goes on to exalt America and Americans. Now please don’t get me wrong, I am as American as the next person and I believe we are a great country, but I also believe in giving credit where credit is due. I am not xenophobic, even though I am afraid our friend Glenn Beck might be.
He goes on to say “everybody was by candlelight. America came around and boom – everything changed … and America came along and man’s imagination, the whole world changed because of the ideas of our Founders.” Now granted our Founders had some wonderful ideas but none as Beck suggests when he says that “so it was just about the light bulb and the steam engine and then the gasoline engine and television and radio and all that stuff?” Mr. Beck did you not pay attention in history class?
Let us start with the light bulb – I know many say that Thomas Edison invented the light bulb, but really he just improved on it, it was actually invented by Joseph Swan who received a patent in the United Kingdom for a partial vacuum, carbon filament incandescent lamp. A year before Edison applied for a patent, Swan was installing light bulbs in homes IN ENGLAND. *
Next, the steam engine, Thomas Savery in 1698 patented the first crude steam engine, IN ENGLAND. Then around 1712 Thomas Newcomen improved the steam engine, still IN ENGLAND. James Watt, you know the guy the WATT is named after, improved on it even more IN SCOTLAND. *
Now on to the gasoline engine, again not an American invention. Siegfried Marcus an AUSTRIAN is believed to have built the first gas powered engine. With other fueled engines being created by various individuals from 1680 and on.*
The radio was invented by Marconi and Nikola Tesla, ITALIANS. Tesla was the first to receive a patent for radio technology.
I’ll be honest, I did not know all the people who made these inventions, I did know they weren’t invented by Americans. I looked them up and I found most of my answers on About.com. I checked other sites to cross-reference, and these guys are generally considered to be the inventors. This is to illustrate to you how far-out Glenn Beck can be, but wait, it gets even better.
He then introduced a report Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World. He says that is a government report, which it is, it was complied by the National Intelligence Council (NIC). However, Beck wants you to believe this report was created by the Obama Administration, and it is basically a blueprint on how they are going to change things. Well let’s start at the beginning, the report was printed in November of 2008, which would mean it would need to be compiled before that. Who was in office then? Obama? No, I don’t think so, I believe it was Bush, George W., to be exact. The head of the NIC, C. Thomas Fingar, was in office during the time of the Bush administration, and left in 2008.
Beck continues and takes the report totally out of context, remember the title, GLOBAL, “…but it is concentrating under more state control.” The only thing is the report is not talking of states as in United States, but rather China, Russia and the Gulf States. They are mentioned numerous times though out the report. He goes on to say “in the wake of the 2008 global financial crisis, the state’s role in the economy may be gaining more appeal throughout the world. Understand what that means. That means that the model of China is the goal that these guys are saying, everybody is pretty cool with. This is what is going to come.” In the report on page 8, Beck gets this information; however, the report does not mean the United States here, this is under the heading State Capitalism: A Post-Democratic Marketplace Rising in the East? So the report is talking of the east, not the west, as in US. In the second paragraph just after the talking point about state’s role, it mentions China, Russia, and Gulf states. A few paragraphs later it goes on to say “…may reinforce the emerging countries’ preference for greater state control and distrust of an unregulated marketplace. So we can safely say the report is not speaking of America. (page eight of report)
Glenn Beck goes on to say “state-owned enterprise serve as secondary function as pressure valves, helping to relieve inflation and currency appreciation pressures. They can also act as vehicles for increased political control. Increased political control – just what every American has dreamt about.” The report says “SOEs, especially national oil companies,” so we can safely assume again, not meaning state-owned as in America. The report then goes on to say, “the increasing role of the state as a player in the emerging markets has contrasted until recently with nearly opposite trends in the West, where the state has struggled to keep pace with private financial engineering…” It continues with, “…a gap on the role of the state in the economy is likely to remain between the West and the rapidly emerging economic powers.” So again we can gather since the report is saying opposite trends in the west, the report is not speaking of states as in United States. (page 9, 10, & 11) Unfortunately hearing Beck tell, he infers this means the United States of America.
Beck then continues, “and then there was this statement: In terms of size, speed and directional flow, the transfer of global wealth and economic power now underway roughly form West to East is without precedent in modern history. This is said in the report, under Executive Summary, and the report goes on to explain this is due to two reasons – one, “increases in oil and commodity prices generated windfall profits for the Gulf states and Russia.” Two, “lower costs combined with government policies have shifted the locus of manufacturing and some service industries to Asia. Beck is correct in this. However, since the report is about contingencies and what could happened if certain paths are followed, and if a nation doesn’t like what it is seeing, there are other paths to follow to change the outcome. Maybe we should change the outcome then and bring back manufacturing to the US and stop our dependency on oil and look for other natural alternatives.
Then the insanity continues on his show, he brings out experts; John Bolton, former US ambassador to the UN, Stuart Varney host of Fox Business Network and Daniel Hannan, a member of the European Parliament. Both Bolton and Varney are quick to infer that this report is the brain child of the Obama administration. Varney even goes on to say, “The worldview of the Obama administration and of the president, himself, is embedded in that report. He’s looking at the America that we have now, that he has partly helped to create with his polices of the last 18 months and he’s projecting that into the future, into the world. And it’s a future view, which I personally reject and I think we will reverse. But there’s no question, THAT REPORT ENCAPSULATES OBAMA’S VIEW OF THE WORLD NOW AND IN THE FUTURE. It is, however, reversible.” Page formatting for emphasis added by me.
I can’t say it enough. THIS REPORT IS NOT FROM THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION BUT FROM BUSH’S It is not about Obama’s worldview, but from the NIC of ’08 along with others, globally, that helped to compile the information.
My point is, do not believe everything you hear, please take the time to read and look up what is being said. I always hear I am busy, I have a life, well so do I, I Freelance for a local paper and other online sites; besides dealing with two crushing illnesses. Yet I can take the time to read a 99 page document, find transcripts for Glenn Beck’s show and post about it.
I am adding I emailed Mr. C. Thomas Fingar to make sure that what I was reading and understanding was correct. I am enclosing that email and his answer. Now my question to Glenn Beck is, did you read this report? If so, why couldn’t you have Mr. Fingar on your show to back your accusations? or if that was not possible as least fire off an email and do like I did, this is what I am gathering from reading the report am I correct? It actually would have saved you all that time it took to put together your show.
For my readers: the email I sent off to make sure my points were correct.
Dear Mr. Fingar,
I hope you don’t mind me emailing you to ask a few questions regarding the Global Trend 2025: A Transformed World report. I am sure you are aware of Glenn Beck using your report on his Friday October 1 show. During the show Mr. Beck insinuates the report was written by the Obama Administration; however, when I downloaded the report I noticed a date of November 2008, so I conclude that the report was compiled and written during the Bush Administration.
I do have a few questions and I hope you can answer them for me.
1) throughout the report it mentions states, such as, state control, state capitalism, state’s role in the economy. It my understanding of the report that when states are mentioned it is not meaning the states of America but states within Russia, China – elsewhere in the world. Is this correct?
2) you mention Gulf states, I am assuming you do not meant as in states bordering the Gulf of Mexico but rather the Middle East as in the Persian Gulf.
3) I am also coming away from reading this report that the US will still remain a democracy and our impact on how all this will come about will still be a driving factor. It will not just be the US affected but other countries as well, this is a global report not national. Please correct me if I am wrong. Also we will still be the most important but not necessarily the most dominant.
4) Also when State Owned Enterprises (SOE) are spoken of it is meaning national entities and not, for example, New York as a state owned enterprise?
5) On page 8 it says “In the wake of the 2008 global financial crisis, the state’s role in the economy may be gaining more appeal throughout the world,” this is not meaning states as NY, CT, WA, Ca as examples, but as in China, Russia and Gulf states?
Thank you for taking your time with me.
Sincerely,
Cathy von Hassel-Davies
Mr. Thomas Fingar’s response:
You are correct on all points except the statement that the US will still be the most important but not necessarily the most dominant. The US will still be the most dominant in 2025 but the magnitude of our dominance will diminish as a result of the rise of many other nations, not because of US decline.
*About.com Inventions
Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World
Transcripts of Glenn Beck show October 1, 2010
Cathy von Hassel-Davies
(336) 525-1228